Lukas Lewark, Andrew Lobb
We construct smooth concordance invariants of knots which take the form of piecewise linear maps from [0,1] to R, one for each n greater than or equal to 2. These invariants arise from sl(n) knot cohomology. We verify some properties which are analogous to those of the invariant Upsilon (which arises from knot Floer homology), and some which differ. We make some explicit computations and give some topological applications. Further to this, we define a concordance invariant from equivariant sl(n) knot cohomology which subsumes many known concordance invariants arising from quantum knot cohomologies.
Joshua Evan Greene, Andrew Lobb
We prove that for every smooth Jordan curve $γ\subset \mathbb{C}$ and for every set $Q \subset \mathbb{C}$ of six concyclic points, there exists a non-constant quadratic polynomial $p \in \mathbb{C}[z]$ such that $p(Q) \subset γ$. The proof relies on a theorem of Fukaya and Irie. We also prove that if $Q$ is the union of the vertex sets of two concyclic regular $n$-gons, there exists a non-constant polynomial $p \in \mathbb{C}[z]$ of degree at most $n-1$ such that $p(Q) \subset γ$. The proof is based on a computation in Floer homology. These results support a conjecture about which point sets $Q \subset \mathbb{C}$ admit a polynomial inscription of a given degree into every smooth Jordan curve $γ$.
Dan Jones, Andrew Lobb, Dirk Schuetz
We pursue the analogy of a framed flow category with the flow data of a Morse function. In classical Morse theory, Morse functions can sometimes be locally altered and simplified by the Morse moves. These moves include the Whitney trick which removes two oppositely framed flowlines between critical points of adjacent index and handle cancellation which removes two critical points connected by a single flowline. A framed flow category is a way of encoding flow data such as that which may arise from the flowlines of a Morse function or of a Floer functional. The Cohen-Jones-Segal construction associates a stable homotopy type to a framed flow category whose cohomology is designed to recover the corresponding Morse or Floer cohomology. We obtain analogues of the Whitney trick and of handle cancellation for framed flow categories: in this new setting these are moves that can be performed to simplify a framed flow category without changing the associated stable homotopy type. These moves often enable one to compute by hand the stable homotopy type associated to a framed flow category. We apply this in the setting of the Lipshitz-Sarkar stable homotopy type (corresponding to Khovanov cohomology) and the stable homotopy type of a matched diagram due to the authors (corresponding to sl_n Khovanov-Rozansky cohomology).
John A. Baldwin, Matthew Hedden, Andrew Lobb
We introduce the notion of a Khovanov-Floer theory. Roughly, such a theory assigns a filtered chain complex over Z/2 to a link diagram such that (1) the E_2 page of the resulting spectral sequence is naturally isomorphic to the Khovanov homology of the link; (2) this filtered complex behaves nicely under planar isotopy, disjoint union, and 1-handle addition; and (3) the spectral sequence collapses at the E_2 page for any diagram of the unlink. We prove that a Khovanov-Floer theory naturally yields a functor from the link cobordism category to the category of spectral sequences. In particular, every page (after E_1) of the spectral sequence accompanying a Khovanov-Floer theory is a link invariant, and an oriented cobordism in R^3 \times [0,1] between links in R^3 induces a map between each page of their spectral sequences, invariant up to smooth isotopy of the cobordism rel boundary. We then show that the spectral sequences relating Khovanov homology to Heegaard Floer homology and singular instanton knot homology are induced by Khovanov-Floer theories and are therefore functorial in the manner described above, as has been conjectured for some time. We further show that Szabo's geometric spectral sequence comes from a Khovanov-Floer theory, and is thus functorial as well. In addition, we illustrate how our framework can be used to give another proof that Lee's spectral sequence is functorial and that Rasmussen's invariant is a knot invariant. Finally, we use this machinery to define some potentially new knot invariants.
Andrew Lobb
We show that the information contained in the associated graded vector space to Gornik's version of Khovanov-Rozansky knot homology is equivalent to a single even integer s_n(K). Furthermore we show that s_n is a homomorphism from the smooth knot concordance group to the integers. This is in analogy with Rasmussen's invariant coming from a perturbation of Khovanov homology.
Peter Feller, Lukas Lewark, Andrew Lobb
We prove that any link admitting a diagram with a single negative crossing is strongly quasipositive. This answers a question of Stoimenow's in the (strong) positive. As a second main result, we give simple and complete characterizations of link diagrams with quasipositive canonical surface (the surface produced by Seifert's algorithm). As applications, we determine which prime knots up to 13 crossings are strongly quasipositive, and we confirm the following conjecture for knots that have a canonical surface realizing their genus: a knot is strongly quasipositive if and only if the Bennequin inequality is an equality.
Andrew Lobb
We use the Dold-Whitney theorem classifying $SO(3)$-bundles over a 4-complex to give a mod 4 obstruction to a 2-component link of trivial linking number being slice. It turns out that this coincides with the reduction of the Sato-Levine invariant.
Joshua Evan Greene, Andrew Lobb
We show that there always exists an inscribed square in a Jordan curve given as the union of two graphs of functions of Lipschitz constant less than $1 + \sqrt{2}$. We are motivated by Tao's result that there exists such a square in the case of Lipschitz constant less than $1$. In the case of Lipschitz constant $1$, we show that the Jordan curve inscribes rectangles of every similarity class. Our approach involves analysing the change in the spectral invariants of the Jordan Floer homology under perturbations of the Jordan curve.
Andrew Lobb
Ribbon concordance gives a partial order on knot types, and applying a knot homology functor to a ribbon concordance gives an inclusion of the homologies. The question of the existence of global ribbon minima in each concordance class is a generalization of the slice-ribbon conjecture, which asserts that the unknot is the global minimum in its class. We show that the (reduced rational) Khovanov homology of the (4,5) torus knot is a summand in the Khovanov homology of any knot in its concordance class.
Andrew Lobb
We show that the torus knot $T_{4,9}$ bounds a smooth Möbius band in the $4$-ball, giving a counterexample to Batson's non-orientable analogue of Milnor's conjecture on the smooth slice genera of torus knots.
Andrew Lobb
Given a diagram D of a knot K, we give easily computable bounds for Rasmussen's concordance invariant s(K). The bounds are not independent of the diagram D chosen, but we show that for diagrams satisfying a given condition the bounds are tight. As a corollary we improve on previously known Bennequin-type bounds on the slice genus.
Andrew Lobb
Kanenobu has given infinite families of knots with the same HOMFLY polynomials. We show that these knots also have the same sl(n) and HOMFLY homologies, thus giving the first example of an infinite family of knots undistinguishable by these invariants. This is a consequence of a structure theorem about the homologies of knots obtained by twisting up the ribbon of a ribbon knot with one ribbon.
Peter Feller, Lukas Lewark, Andrew Lobb
We study the space of slice-torus invariants. In particular we characterize the set of values that slice-torus invariants may take on a given knot in terms of the stable smooth slice genus. Our study reveals that the resolution of the local Thom conjecture implies the existence of slice torus invariants without having to appeal to any explicit construction from a knot homology theory.
Andrew Lobb, Patrick Orson, Dirk Schuetz
We describe a calculus of moves for modifying a framed flow category without changing the associated stable homotopy type. We use this calculus to show that if two framed flow categories give rise to the same stable homotopy type of homological width at most three, then the flow categories are move equivalent. The process we describe is essentially algorithmic and can often be performed by hand, without the aid of a computer program.
Andrew Lobb, Patrick Orson, Dirk Schuetz
The Lipshitz-Sarkar stable homotopy link invariant defines Steenrod squares on the Khovanov cohomology of a link. Lipshitz-Sarkar constructed an algorithm for computing the first two Steenrod squares. We develop a new algorithm which implements the flow category simplification techniques previously defined by the authors and Dan Jones. We give a purely combinatorial approach to calculating the second Steenrod square and Bockstein homomorphisms in Khovanov cohomology, and flow categories in general. The new method has been implemented in a computer program by the third author and applied to large classes of knots and links. Several homotopy types not previously witnessed are observed, and more evidence is obtained that Khovanov stable homotopy types do not contain $\mathbb{C} P^2$ as a wedge summand. In fact, we are led by our calculations to formulate an even stronger conjecture in terms of $\mathbb{Z}/2$ summands of the cohomology.
Andrew Lobb, Raphael Zentner
We associate a moduli problem to a colored trivalent graph; such graphs, when planar, appear in the state-sum description of the quantum sl(N) knot polynomial due to Murakami, Ohtsuki, and Yamada. We discuss how the resulting moduli space can be thought of a representation variety. We show that the Euler characteristic of the moduli space is equal to the quantum sl(N) polynomial of the graph evaluated at unity. Possible extensions of the result are also indicated.
Lukas Lewark, Andrew Lobb
It is well-known that generic perturbations of the complex Frobenius algebra used to define Khovanov cohomology each give rise to Rasmussen's concordance invariant s. This gives a concordance homomorphism to the integers and a strong lower bound on the smooth slice genus of a knot. Similar behavior has been observed in sl(n) Khovanov-Rozansky cohomology, where a perturbation gives rise to the concordance homomorphisms s_n for each n >= 2, and where we have s_2 = s. We demonstrate that s_n for n >= 3 does not in fact arise generically, and that varying the chosen perturbation gives rise both to new concordance homomorphisms as well as to new sliceness obstructions that are not equivalent to concordance homomorphisms.
Andrew Lobb, Patrick Orson, Dirk Schuetz
We extend Lipshitz-Sarkar's definition of a stable homotopy type associated to a link L whose cohomology recovers the Khovanov cohomology of L. Given an assignment c (called a coloring) of positive integer to each component of a link L, we define a stable homotopy type X_col(L_c) whose cohomology recovers the c-colored Khovanov cohomology of L. This goes via Rozansky's definition of a categorified Jones-Wenzl projector P_n as an infinite torus braid on n strands. We then observe that Cooper-Krushkal's explicit definition of P_2 also gives rise to stable homotopy types of colored links (using the restricted palette {1, 2}), and we show that these coincide with X_col. We use this equivalence to compute the stable homotopy type of the (2,1)-colored Hopf link and the 2-colored trefoil. Finally, we discuss the Cooper-Krushkal projector P_3 and make a conjecture of X_col(U_3) for U the unknot.
Joshua Evan Greene, Andrew Lobb
For every smooth Jordan curve $γ$ and cyclic quadrilateral $Q$ in the Euclidean plane, we show that there exists an orientation-preserving similarity taking the vertices of $Q$ to $γ$. The proof relies on the theorem of Polterovich and Viterbo that an embedded Lagrangian torus in $\mathbb{C}^2$ has minimum Maslov number 2.
Andrew Lobb
Given a knot, we ask how its Khovanov and Khovanov-Rozansky homologies change under the operation of introducing twists in a pair of strands. We obtain long exact sequences in homology and further algebraic structure which is then used to derive topological and computational results. Two of our applications include giving a new way to generate arbitrary numbers of knots with isomorphic homologies and finding an infinite number of mutant knot pairs with isomorphic reduced homologies.