Is Praesepe really different from the coeval Hyades cluster? The XMM-Newton view

The Praesepe open cluster represents a puzzle since it has about the same age as the Hyades, and only slightly different metallicity, yet previous ROSAT observations resulted in a detection rate of cluster sources significantly lower than for the Hyades. We present a new 50 ksec observation of Praesepe performed with the EPIC instrument on board XMM- Newton , which resulted in the detection of ~200 sources, including 48 cluster members. We detected all solar-type (F–G) stars in the field of view, ~90% of the K stars and ~70% of the M stars. We find that the distribution of X-ray luminosities of solar-type Praesepe members is comparable to that of the Hyades, in contrast with the previous ROSAT results; however, the disagreement between the ROSAT and XMM- Newton results appears to be mostly due to X-ray faint Praesepe members falling outside the XMM- Newton field of view, while it is considerably reduced when considering only the subsample of stars in the ROSAT survey in common with the present observation. The finding supports an earlier suggestion that Praesepe may be formed by two merged clusters of different age.