CHILES IX: Observational and Simulated HI Content and Star Formation of Blue Galaxies in Different Cosmic Web Environments

We examine the redshift evolution of the relationship between the neutral atomic hydrogen ({\HI}) content and star-formation properties of blue galaxies, along with their location in the cosmic web. Using the COSMOS {\HI} Large Extragalactic Survey (CHILES) and the IllustrisTNG (TNG100) cosmological simulation, and the {\disperse} algorithm, we identify the filamentary structure in both observations and simulations, measure the distance of galaxies to the nearest filament spine {\dfil}, and calculate the mean {\HI} gas fraction and the relative specific star formation rate (sSFR) of blue galaxies in three different cosmic web environments -- $0<{\dfil}/\mathrm{Mpc}<2$ (filament cores), $2<{\dfil}/\mathrm{Mpc}<4$ (filament outskirts), and $4<{\dfil}/\mathrm{Mpc}<20$ (voids). We find that, although there are some similarities between CHILES and TNG, there exist significant discrepancies in the dependence of {\HI} and star formation on the cosmic web and on redshift. TNG overpredicts the observed {\HI} fraction and relative sSFR at $z=0-0.5$, with the tension being strongest in the voids. CHILES observes a decline in the {\HI} fraction from filament cores to voids, exactly the opposite of the trend predicted by TNG. CHILES observes an increase in {\HI} fraction at $z=0.5\rightarrow0$ in the voids, while TNG predicts an increase in this time in all environments. Further dividing the sample into stellar mass bins, we find that the {\HI} in ${\logms}>10$ galaxies is better reproduced by TNG than {\HI} in ${\logms}=9-10$ galaxies.