A Convex Form That Is Not a Sum of Squares

Every convex homogeneous polynomial (or form) is nonnegative. Blekherman has shown that there exist convex forms that are not sums of squares via a nonconstructive argument. We provide an explicit example of a convex form of degree 4 in 272 variables that is not a sum of squares. The form is related to the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality over the octonions. The proof uses symmetry reduction together with the fact (due to Blekherman) that forms of even degree that are near-constant on the unit sphere are convex. Using this same connection, we obtain improved bounds on the approximation quality achieved by the basic sum-of-squares relaxation for optimizing quaternary quartic forms on the sphere.